Resale Record

Home / Blog

How to decide what a thrift find is worth before you buy it

A hand holding a vintage camera in a thrift store aisle

The cheapest mistake in reselling is not buying something. The expensive one is buying something you cannot sell for much more than you paid. A short routine in the aisle prevents most of it.

1. Look at sold, not listed

Search for the item and filter to sold listings. Asking prices show what sellers hope for. Sold prices show what buyers did. Here is how to read them.

2. Check the condition match

A sold comp is only a comp if it matches: same model, same size, same condition, working or not. A mint one and a scuffed one can be far apart.

3. Work backwards from your margin

Take a realistic sale price and subtract fees, shipping and supplies (see the full profit calculation). What is left is the most you can pay and still hit your target.

Many resellers set a rule, such as "I need to at least triple my cost" or "I need $15 profit after fees". The rule matters less than having one.

4. Be honest about speed

An item that sells in three days at a small margin often beats one that sits for three months at a large one. Cash tied up in slow stock cannot buy the next good find.

5. Write it down at the moment

Once you buy, log it while you are still holding the receipt. In Resale Record a pickup takes under a minute, and the cost is saved so the sale has something to be compared with later.

A note on comps

Comparable sales are a guide, not a promise. Photos, title and timing move a final price, and the market can change quickly.

Keep your resale books in one place

Resale Record logs pickups, tracks sales, mileage and expenses, and has your Schedule C export ready at tax time. It is on Google Play for Android, and in a private beta on TestFlight for iPhone and iPad.

Get it on Google Play   or request iPhone beta access

General information, not tax advice. Check anything that affects your return with a tax preparer.